Faith Fairchild’s friend and neighbor, Pix Rowe Miller, is excited about her son’s out-of-town wedding. But she’s also worried about leaving her elderly mother, Ursula, who has suddenly fallen ill. True to her good nature, Faith offers to keep an eye on the dear older woman.

As Faith soon discovers, however, Ursula’s illness stems not from age but from worry—concern and fear over a dark family secret she’s been carrying for more than seventy years. In the desperate years of the Depression, Ursula’s brother Theo was brutally murdered—his killer sent away. Now, a mysterious letter has arrived under her door, asking the question: Are you sure you were right?

Faith can’t help being drawn into solving the decades-old murder. But before she can find the truth she’s got a pressing—and very personal—mystery at hand. The discretionary fund at the church has been pilfered, and the Reverend Thomas Fai